Taliban restrictions on women's artistic expression highlighted
A former Afghan Film director highlighted Taliban restrictions on women's artistic expression in an interview, detailing the impact on the country's cultural sector.
The Full Story
A plain summary built from the channels that reported this story.
Five years after the Taliban returned to power in Afghanistan, the country's cultural sector has been hollowed out, with women and girls stripped of the ability to express themselves through art, music, and film. Sara Karimi, the former director-general of Afghan Film, the state cinema regulator, said in an interview that everything has changed. "So art is forbidden, music is forbidden, cinema became crime, act of crime," she said. Karimi, who was the first woman to head the institution, explained that women filmmakers and artists have been forced into hiding or exile. Those who remain in Afghanistan are afraid to reveal their past activities, and many have changed their names and addresses. Secret book clubs, poetry classes, and writing groups have emerged as acts of resistance, but they carry great risk. "If the Taliban know that somebody is publishing online poetry, or publishing online story, they arrest them," she said. More than two million students are not going to school, and many of them were art students.
The Taliban's fifth anniversary celebrations in Kabul on Saturday underscored the regime's confidence. Armoured vehicles rolled into Masoud Square outside the former US embassy, and sports events were held, but women and girls were banned from attending. The celebrations came as Afghans continue to face deepening poverty, drought, and steep cuts in foreign aid. Chief international correspondent Lyse Doucet reported from Kabul that the country is more peaceful, but Afghans are battling other challenges, including a growing list of rules erasing women and girls from public life. Women cannot go to parks, girls cannot attend school beyond grade six, and women are barred from many jobs.
The restrictions have also hit sports. The Afghan women's football team, which was banned from organised sport and forced into exile, has reunited and played two friendlies in Auckland against the Cook Islands. This was the first time FIFA allowed Afghanistan's team in exile back into international football. The players said they want to prove they are still fighting for their rights. "We want Afghanistan to be free and we want Afghan girls and women to be free to be able to choose who they want to be," one player said. The team aims to compete for a place at the 2028 Olympic Games.
Political pressure is building for international recognition of the situation as gender apartheid. Councillor Peymana Asad, the first British Afghan official elected in the UK, said Afghans feel betrayed by their allies. She listed the extensive restrictions on women, including bans on education, employment, travel without a male chaperone, and access to public spaces. She is leading a campaign to have gender apartheid formally recognised under UK law and at the UN, which would allow Afghan women to take the Taliban to the International Court of Justice. The UK government has so far refused to support the codification, saying it is waiting for South Africa, which recently recognised gender apartheid alongside Malala Yousafzai. Asad warned against the normalisation of the Taliban, saying the regime is telling everyone it will soon be formally recognised.
The situation for women in Afghanistan remains dire, with the highest suicide rate in the world and the highest maternal mortality rate, according to Asad. Karimi echoed this, saying the situation is "very, very dark" and that girls cannot even dream about tomorrow. Yet she noted that women and girls are not giving up, continuing to write and create in secret. The international community, she said, should think about the women of Afghanistan.
On screen
Stills are sampled automatically at 60-second intervals. Where shown, the still is the nearest available frame from the relevant broadcast segment and is included to show what was on screen during that part of the broadcast. A still may not correspond to the exact second of a quoted phrase.
Key Claims
Claims reported during this story's coverage, mapped by channel. Ordered by how many channels carried each claim.
| Claim | BBC News | BBC One |
|---|---|---|
| The Taliban have remained in control of Afghanistan five years after taking Kabul. | ||
| Afghan women and girls face bans on education, government employment, NGOs, and the UN, along with restrictions on travel and public life. | · | |
| Afghanistan is experiencing a growing humanitarian crisis with record levels of hunger and malnutrition. | · | |
| Afghanistan remains under international sanctions linked to terrorism and human rights, and its assets are frozen. | · | |
| Afghanistan's women's team played two friendlies against the Cook Islands in Auckland, losing both, and considered wearing their country's colours a victory. | · | |
| Councillor Peymana Asad is leading a campaign for the UK to recognise gender apartheid in Afghanistan under the CEDAW convention. | · | |
| FIFA changed its rules to give the Afghan women's football team a path back to the international stage. | · | |
| Most female filmmakers and actors have left Afghanistan, and those remaining are in hiding and have changed identities. | · | |
| South Africa recently recognised that gender apartheid is happening in Afghanistan, standing alongside Malala Yousafzai. | · | |
| The Afghan women's football team aims to compete for a place at the 2028 Olympic Games. | · | |
| The Afghan women's football team is banned from all organised sport in Afghanistan. | · | |
| The Taliban made artistic expression, including film, music and poetry, illegal for women. | · |
Channel Perspectives
What each channel focused on, with key quotes.
BBC NEWS provided a comprehensive look at the impact on women's artistic expression, featuring an exclusive interview with Sara Karimi, and also highlighted the football team's story and the political campaign for gender apartheid. The tone was empathetic and action-oriented, giving voice to Afghan women and stressing the need for international recognition and support.
- “So art is forbidden, music is forbidden, cinema became crime, act of crime.”
- “Women of Afghanistan, girls of Afghanistan trying very much to survive, and any act that they are doing in secret is act of resistance.”
- “We have been leading a campaign in the UK to try and get the UK government to recognize gender apartheid formally at the UN under the CEDAW convention.”
BBC ONE West focused on the broader fifth anniversary coverage, with Lyse Doucet's on-the-ground report from Kabul highlighting the economy, women's rights, and the hunger crisis. It did not include the artistic expression angle or the football team's story, instead concentrating on the overall humanitarian situation and the need for a different relationship with the world.
- “A big issue, the rights of women and girls. A growing list of rules is erasing Afghan women and girls from public life.”
- “Afghanistan needs a different relationship with the world.”
Broadcast Timeline
News broadcasts tracked for this story, in time order.