Criminal Justice

View all Criminal Justice stories →

BBC ONE West and BBC NEWS reported that the government is scrapping plans to restrict some jury trials in England and Wales. The proposals, made during Sir Keir Starmer's time as Prime Minister, would have allowed judge-only trials for cases where the sentence would be less than three years. The reports said Justice Secretary Alex Norris, who was sworn in as Lord Chancellor this week, said dropping the proposals would speed up work to reduce a backlog of around 80,000 Crown Court cases. The judge-only element was described as the most complicated to implement and one that would have held up the wider package. The reports said critics across the criminal justice world had argued there was no evidence the jury plan would solve court delays, and many said ministers needed to fund more judges, which they had now done. The channels reported that barristers who campaigned to save jury trials welcomed the decision, and they included comments that public confidence is strongest when 12 people decide the facts together and that the move was common sense. Shadow Justice Secretary Nick Timothy also welcomed the change. The reports placed the decision alongside early releases of prisoners. They said 700 prisoners were released early this week to stop jails running out of space, and around 4,500 offenders are due to be released early by next summer, many serving long sentences for serious crimes. The Probation Service union was reported to be worried that its members cannot monitor all those released and might strike. Alex Norris could not say how many of those released early since Thursday had been tagged, saying it was too soon to know. On domestic abuse, he said the government would have liked to go further but the alternative would have been no prison places, meaning perpetrators would be bailed back to their homes. The reports said it could take years before the criminal justice system returns to normal, with courts running at speed and the right people in prison.

Key Claims by Channel

Sunday 23 August 2026

Claim
Reported by all 2 channels
The government is introducing restriction zones for serious offenders after release from prison, including probation funding and GPS monitoring.	Reported by Channel 5	Reported by Sky News

Friday 25 September 2026

Claim
Reported by all 2 channels
Zafar Dogan was sentenced to more than two years in prison for taking thousands of images of women and children and using AI to enhance some into explicit images.		Reported by Channel 4
Zafar Dogan had previously been bailed to a home overlooking a children's playground, where he targeted some of his victims.		Reported by Channel 4
Zafar Dogan, aged 32, was convicted of child sexual abuse image offences, including AI-generated material.	Reported by BBC One	Reported by Channel 4
Dogan used AI software to generate indecent images from photographs and recordings of children and women, including thousands of images taken from his flat window overlooking a playground.	Reported by BBC One	Reported by Channel 4
Sir Mark Rowley criticised bail decisions, saying they let victims down, prioritised offenders over victims' safety, and were influenced by pressure to reduce the remand population.	Reported by BBC One	Reported by Channel 4
Daniel Thomas pleaded not guilty to criminal damage over footage of him slashing a dinghy carrying people across the English Channel, requested a jury trial, and is due at Portsmouth Crown Court on Tuesday.	Reported by BBC One	Reported by Channel 4
Only on one channel
The flat where Dogan committed the offences was in Enfield.	Reported by BBC One	Not reported by Channel 4
Dogan remained on bail until he was sentenced.	Reported by BBC One	Not reported by Channel 4
A victim's commissioner said the court system had failed the children.	Reported by BBC One	Not reported by Channel 4
The Prime Minister called on the court system to examine the bail decision.	Reported by BBC One	Not reported by Channel 4
The government said bail should be used only when necessary and proportionate, while the Ministry of Justice said final bail decisions rest with the independent judiciary.	Reported by BBC One	Not reported by Channel 4
The number of people on bail from crown courts rose from over 15,000 in 2019 to over 47,000 in 2026, a tripling.	Not reported by BBC One	Reported by Channel 4
The Internet Watch Foundation identified more than 8,000 AI-generated child sexual abuse images last year, including 100 recorded daily in England and Wales, a 14% increase.	Not reported by BBC One	Reported by Channel 4
The victim's family said they felt forced to move away and lived in temporary accommodation.	Reported by BBC One	Not reported by Channel 4

Sunday 4 October 2026

Claim
Reported by all 2 channels
Plans to restrict the use of jury trials in some cases in England and Wales are being dropped by the government.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One
The jury trial restrictions were proposed during Sir Keir Starmer's premiership.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One
The proposed plans would have allowed judges to decide cases alone where the potential sentence was under three years.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One
Alex Norris was sworn in as Lord Chancellor this week and serves as Justice Secretary.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One
Alex Norris said scrapping the plans would help speed up work to reduce a backlog of about 80,000 Crown Court cases in England and Wales.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One
Alex Norris said the judge-only element of the plans was the most complicated to implement and would have held up the entire package.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One
Critics in the criminal justice system told Alex Norris there was no evidence the jury plan would address court delays.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One
Many critics argued the government should simply fund more judges, which ministers have now done.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One
Shadow Justice Secretary Nick Timothy welcomed the decision and described jury trials as an ancient right.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One
About 700 prisoners were released early this week to prevent prisons running out of space.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One
Around 4,500 offenders are expected to have been released early by next summer, including many serving long sentences for serious crimes.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One
The Probation Service Union is concerned its members cannot monitor all early-released prisoners and has raised the possibility of strike action.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One
Alex Norris said it was too soon to know how many prisoners released early since Thursday had been tagged.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One
Alex Norris said he and the Prime Minister would have liked to go further on domestic abuse, but the alternative was no prison places, which could mean perpetrators being bailed home.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One
Reports cited the view that confidence in verdicts is the most important aspect of criminal justice and that decisions by 12 people discussing the facts carry the most public confidence.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One
Reports warned it could take years for the criminal justice system to return to normal, with courts running at speed and the right people behind bars.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One
Barristers who led the campaign to save jury trials welcomed the decision.	Reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One

This is a cross-channel consensus summary, not an objective account. Consensus can be uniformly wrong, or omit what only one channel covered.