Wildlife

View all Wildlife stories →

Channels reported on a new World Wildlife Fund report on wildlife populations and conservation. BBC ONE WestHD said the report highlighted the recovery of Atlantic and Pacific bluefin tuna, tigers, green turtles and some elephant populations as evidence that conservation can work, while warning that these successes are fragile. Channel 4 HD also reported that bluefin tuna are one of several species saved from decline by conservation efforts. Both channels said bluefin tuna had largely disappeared from UK waters and are now back in large numbers. BBC ONE WestHD added that they are now seen off Cornwall in sufficient numbers for fishing competitions. The report's wider findings were less positive. BBC ONE WestHD reported that the 36,000 animal populations tracked by WWF have declined by three quarters since 1970, and that extinction rates, vulnerability to extinction risk and habitat loss are still rising. Channel 4 HD reported a 73% loss of many other wild animal populations globally since 1970. BBC ONE WestHD said WWF presented bluefin tuna as a case study, citing slashed international fishing quotas, protected spawning grounds, consumer, chef and retailer pressure, and mandatory catch-and-release in amateur fishing. It also reported WWF's estimate that for every pound spent protecting nature, around 33 go into activities that harm it. BBC ONE WestHD reported that WWF identified habitat destruction from agricultural expansion, overharvesting, illegal poaching and fossil fuel driven climate change as drivers of decline, and that in an interview WWF's chief scientist said conservation can work with focus but there are not enough resources to act species by species, with food, energy and finance systems needing to be addressed.

Key Claims by Channel

Claim
Widely reported · 3 or more of 4 channels
A WWF report highlights recoveries of Atlantic and Pacific bluefin tuna, tigers, green turtles and some elephant populations as evidence that conservation can work.	Not reported by Channel 5
WWF reported that the 36,000 animal populations it monitors have declined by about three quarters since 1970.			Reported by BBC One
Bluefin tuna had largely disappeared from UK waters but have returned in large numbers.	Not reported by Channel 5
Only on one channel
WWF cautioned that recent conservation successes remain fragile.	Not reported by Channel 5		Not reported by BBC One	Not reported by Channel 4
Extinction rates, vulnerability to extinction and habitat loss are continuing to rise.	Not reported by Channel 5	Not reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One	Not reported by Channel 4
Bluefin tuna recovery was attributed to measures including cuts to international fishing quotas, protected spawning grounds, consumer, chef and retailer pressure, and mandatory catch-and-release in amateur fishing.	Not reported by Channel 5	Not reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One	Not reported by Channel 4
WWF estimated that for every pound spent protecting nature, around 33 pounds go into activities that harm it.	Not reported by Channel 5	Not reported by BBC News		Not reported by Channel 4
Reported drivers of species decline include habitat destruction from agricultural expansion, overharvesting and illegal poaching, and climate change from burning fossil fuels.	Not reported by Channel 5	Not reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One	Not reported by Channel 4
WWF's chief scientist said conservation can work when focused, but resources are insufficient to work species by species and food, energy and finance systems need to be addressed.	Not reported by Channel 5	Not reported by BBC News	Reported by BBC One	Not reported by Channel 4
A Scottish restoration project released over 60,000 native oysters across four sites in the Firth of Forth.		Not reported by BBC News	Not reported by BBC One	Not reported by Channel 4
WWF reported that freshwater species populations fell by 85 per cent and Latin America and Caribbean populations fell by 95 per cent, largely due to deforestation.		Not reported by BBC News	Not reported by BBC One	Not reported by Channel 4
WWF reported that conservation efforts have helped Atlantic and Pacific bluefin tuna, tigers, green turtles, and some elephant populations, but said these successes remain fragile.	Not reported by Channel 5		Not reported by BBC One	Not reported by Channel 4

This is a cross-channel consensus summary, not an objective account. Consensus can be uniformly wrong, or omit what only one channel covered.